The Critics' Dilemma - PARAPSYCHOLOGY, MEDIUMS Association Copy Presented to Close Colleague Alan Gauld w/TLS and Hand-Text Corrections by Author, Errors He Blames on His Secretary. Includes Handwritten Notes by Gauld on His Employer's The University of Nottingham Psychology Department letterhead of the Work.

Dewsbury, England: Self-published, Eric Dingwall, 1966. First edition. Original softcover, paper wraps.

A SELF-CONTAINED ARCHIVAL DIALOGUE FROM TWO LEADING FIGURES IN PARAPSCHOLOGICAL/OCCULT INVESTIGATION WORTHY OF A MUSEUM 'S OR INSTITUTIONAL LIBRARY'S SPECIAL COLLECTIONS:  A Premium Acknowledgment & Association Copy of Exceptional Provenance, A TLS with handwritten addendum referencing an error in the book that Dingwall hand-corrects, responding to a letter by Gauld on this very work, and thorough notes on a separate paper on The Critics' Dilemma in Gauld's hand as he analyzes Dingwall's work line-by-line. The highest level of collectability for an association/presentation copy.

Overall Condition: VG+. Toning to cover edges and spine. A few spots of dusts and a stray mark. A few light creases. Interior pages are clean, bright and white and well-preserved beyond a little corner creasing.

BOOK INFO

Self-published by Eric Dingwall in Dewsbury, England in 1966. Bound in its original softcover paper wraps. Collated and complete: [vii], 8-74 pp.

ABOUT THE WORK AND IMPORTANT BACKGROUND

The work essentially lends support to the criticism proffered by Dingwall's close colleague, Trevor Hall, in which he speculates that the esteemed William Crookes was complicit in bolstering the fraudulent mediumship of Florence Cook. Essentially, this leads to a bunch of inside squabbling, accusations and in-fighting within parapsychology investigative circles. The accusation sparked immediate backlash as Crookes was an esteemed physicist, discover of the element thallium, chemist and important inventor and foundational contributor to plasma physics. He also dabbled in Spiritualism, attending a few seances believing in their work (for which he was heavily criticized by his peers). One of the mediums whose abilities he believed in was that of Florence Cook. Florence Eliza Cook (ca 1856 – April 1904) was a medium who claimed to materialize a spirit, 'Katie King'. Cook was repeatedly exposed as a fraud but she managed to trick Crookes who defended her abilities as a medium. Some researchers such as Trevor H. Hall suspected that Crookes had an affair with Cook and was complicit in her fraudulent practices.

EXCEPTIONAL PROVENANCE & ASSOCIATION

(1) The author signs 'Best Wishes from E.J. Dingwall' on the inside front cover. 
(2) Alan Gauld's ex libris sticker is affixed below this signature.
(3) Alan Gauld signs the copy in ink at the head of the title page.
(4) Alan Gauld is one of Dingwall's colleagues that he thanks in the Preface.
(5) Included is a typed, signed letter from Dingwall to Gauld dated January 14,1967 signed 'Ding.  On the back of the letter there is a handwritten postscript by Dingwall where he points out an error in a date in the book that he has hand-corrected himself in the copy gifted to Gauld. The well-known prickly Dingwall blames his secretary for failing to accurately transcribe the correct date from his manuscript of Critics' Dilemma. This is ironic, and would have been humorous to Gauld, as Dingwall was well-known for criticizing others for similar errors.
In the letter, Dingwall is responding to a letter Gauld sent him regarding this very work and some other matters. Dingwall thanks Gauld for some books he sent him but says he doesn't want the book by Leary nor to be associated with him and his work. He then apologizes to Gauld about the 'Myers letters' - referencing Dingwall's inclusion of extracts from them and a diary in Critics' Dilemma (apparently there was a ban on publishing their contents) and other letters. He then criticizes a 'Mrs. N' for withholding publication of certain letters. Dingwall goes on to respond to Gauld's calling out 'plots' related to the matters addressed in Critics' Dilemma. He concludes, 'How right Mrs. Crookes was about Spiritualists and the truth. Yrs, Ding'.

(6) Loosely laid in on Gauld's professional letterhead from The University of Nottingham's Psychology Department is a thorough analysis of Dingwall's book in red ink in Gould's hand. Gould goes through the work, line by line, writing down key points from specific pages and interacting with the text with his observations and musings.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Eric John Dingwall (1890–1986) was a British anthropologist, psychical researcher and librarian. Dingwall was described as an eccentric by those who knew him. He co-edited the four-volume set Abnormal Hypnotic Phenomena (1967–68). The set was described in a review as of considerable historical interest and well written. His book Racial Pride and Prejudice and his books on artificial cranial deformation and infibulation received positive reviews. Dingwall was nicknamed 'Dirty Ding' due to his interests in erotica and sexual customs. He was the honorary vice-president for The Magic Circle and a founding member of its Occult Committee. In the 1920s and 1930s Dingwall travelled widely in Europe and the United States to investigate mediums. He has been described as a skeptical enquirer and a psychical investigator who spent many years exposing fraud and unscientific practices among psychical researchers. He co-wrote the skeptical book Four Modern Ghosts (1958) with Trevor H. Hall which gave rationalistic explanations for alleged supernatural phenomena such as the Yorkshire Museum Ghost and Harry Price's Rosalie materialization séance. Gould's extensive papers are held by the University of London Library, and his horological interests led to a bequest to the British Museum’s Clocks and Watches department.

ABOUT ALAN GAULD

Alan Gauld (1932 - 2024) was a British parapsychologist, psychologist and spiritualist writer best known for his research on the history of hypnotism and mediumship. Gauld was born in Portland, Dorset. In the late 1950s, he attended Harvard University. He obtained an M.S. in 1958 and a PhD in 1962 from Emmanuel College, Cambridge. He taught psychology at the University of Nottingham and was the president of the Society for Psychical Research from 1989 to 1992. Gauld's book A History of Hypnotism (1992) documents the history of hypnosis. It was positively reviewed by medical historian Roger Cooter in the British Medical Journal who recommended it as a 'useful reference tool.' Some other works by Gould: The Founders of Psychical Research (1968), Human Action and its Psychological Investigation [with John Shotter] (1977), Poltergeists (1979) [with Tony Cornell], Andrew Lang as Psychical Researcher (1983), Mediumship and Survival: A Century of Investigations (1983), A History of Hypnotism (1992), and The Heyday of Mental Mediumship: 1880s – 1930s: Investigators, Mediums and Communicators (2022). He received the Award for Outstanding Contribution to Parapsychological Research from the Parapsychological Association and was awarded the Myers Memorial Medal by the Society for Psychical Research.

THEIR RELATIONSHIP

Dingwall and Gauld were exceptionally close colleagues and frequent correspondents with the Society for Psychical Research. Despite Dingwall's notoriously prickly and hyper-skeptical demeanor, Gauld was one of the very few contemporary investigators whose scientific standards Dingwall deeply respected.

. Very Good. Item #485

$2,000.00 save 10% $1,800.00